The truly outrageous acts were uncommon, but of course did make the news....the same as the off the wall stuff makes the news today. Thanks! Would you start a physical confrontation with a trained killer who you believe is also a war criminal? But now we are not forgotten, we have our memorial, we've had our parades." Yet there is also a lot of comprehensive evidence that these stories are urban myths, and that soldiers … I am sure some of the protests were about the war it self but i can only speak to what I have seen from his Navy box and the protests near the Naval bases. Appy, Christian G. Working-class war: American combat soldiers and Vietnam. It all depends on where you are and the time period. The debate in society was about the war, and veterans were as much a part of that debate as everyone else, if not more so. I am personally confused about this issue given the varying levels of experiences and evidence from both sides. They took a bus from the base for protection as the Dept. In short, your friend's claim that veterans' mistreatment is a "myth" is misleading at best. Mistreatment of vets, more often than not, seemed to be a lack of respect or recognition. That is how most of us saw this. That study shows only a handful (32) of instances were presented as in any way antagonistic … For some reason, in the stories it is always an airport where the spitting … Numerous first-hand accounts echo the idea that vets were "forgotten. He also said it wasnt like that every day it only seemed to happen when a Nuclear powered ship was pulling into port. Do you have relatives who are veterans? They were told that they would be spat on. Homecoming: When the Soldiers Returned From Vietnam is a book of selected correspondence published in 1989. In the 1986 Veterans Day ceremony at the Vietnam Memorial, one speaker argued against a perception that "the cause for which we fought was not worthy of your lives." Is it all just an urban myth? Press J to jump to the feed. /r/History is a place for discussions about history. For further discussion on how sourcing works in this subreddit, please consult this thread. He recounts a study of 495 news stories on returning veterans published from 1965 to 1971. The Vietnam War claimed the lives of more than 58,000 American service members and wounded more than 150,000. This list is way out of date. The "spitting" part is a sadly common story, specifically the fact that anti-war protesters/hippies were waiting at airports to spit on veterans returning from combat. There is not a single corroborating news report from that time of any solider being spat upon. They were anti-nuke protesters. ", In the 1986 Veterans Day ceremony at the Vietnam Memorial, one speaker argued against a perception that "the cause for which we fought was not worthy of your lives." During Fourth of July parades, the WWI and WWII and Korean War vets would come out to march, and there were very few Vietnam vets who wanted to participate due to the negative attitude they got from some people. The only contemporary accounts we have of spitting was during the Republican convention in 1972. In fact, the antiwar movement and many veterans were closely aligned, and the only documented incidents show members of the VFW and American Legion spitting on their less successful Vietnam peers. We will either remove it or have someone update it this year (1999). Numerous first-hand accounts echo the idea that vets were "forgotten." I always thought US citizens were mad at the US soldiers because of all the stories of mistreatment they did in Vietnam, like My Lai, and not just because they were soldiers. The Journal editorialized on March 28, that "During the 1960s and 1970s, people opposed to the Vietnam War took out their rage on the wrong … (Flickr/Creative Commons)Investigations have been launched at two universities over accusations that fraternity members taunted wounded war heroes, urinated on an American flag, and spit on a wounded veteran and his … Many vets will tell you it happened, and others will tell you that they never saw anything close to it. For years I had been hearing stories that when American troops returned home from Vietnam, they were spat upon by anti-war protesters. Follow up question: what is the origin for stories of returning Vietnam vets being spit on? In this episode I hope to end the urban myth that Vietnam Vets were spat upon as they returned from fighting in the Vietnam War. What have you guys heard? Stories of spat-upon Vietnam veterans are bogus. It is a myth that returning Vietnam vets were spat upon by antiwar activists when they returned from the war. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. I protested the war, and knew some vets, and I saw them as victims getting squeezed in a vise of public opinion. Chapel Hill, N.C: U of North Carolina Press, 1993. That's not true. Jerry Davich who writes for the Post-Tribune a Chicago Sun Times Publication adds support to my theory that Vietnam Vets were not spit on when they returned. It Was America Versus North Vietnam. Please read the rules before participating, as we remove all comments which break the rules. Not one. That's why it was considered such an outrage... a drafted soldier shouldn't be the scapegoat for the politics of his/her nation. "Choice" -- people were drafted, it wasn't always a choice. Make sure to familiarize yourself with our rules and guidelines before participating. Vietnam veterans were often unwelcome at Veterans Day parades. Veterans were not a monolithic group. This is a somewhat more serious subreddit compared to many others. I was called a baby killer one time by a total stranger. While outright harassment of Vietnam veterans almost certainly did happen, mistreatment of Vietnam veterans was usually a lack of recognition-- a perceived amnesia about the sacrifices made by veterans. ''Most Vietnam veterans were spat on when we came back," he said. Most soldiers drafted after 1968 were antiwar even before they went … The phenomenon of vets being spit on seems to be largely anecdotal so I'm not sure I can faithfully speak to its veracity. Press J to jump to the feed. Were veterans spat upon as they returned from serving in Vietnam? and the protests were bigger in Japan. It's a striking image -- these tired, grizzled men returning from a nightmare, only to be covered in hippie saliva the moment they hit the ground. Continue Reading Below. Web. The Vietnam Memorial. Franklin, Ben A. The military leadership wanted to avoid this, hence the "no uniforms" order. Another speaker noted, "For a long time we were forgotten. I think if some people tried that now, they would be attacked. Far from spitting on veterans, the antiwar movement welcomed them into its ranks and thousands of veterans … But AFAIK the supposed abuse is very likely an urban legend or maybe happened once or twice at most. My son right now is in the Navy and I am so happy at the way people treat him. My father was in the Navy on an aircraft carrier. As I am saying all this way after the fact and have no links to said conversation, feel free to take this with a grain of salt. "NEW YORK PAYS HOMAGE TO VIETNAM VETERANS." During the Vietnam War, Australian army and navy men were told to not wear their uniforms when on leave back home. My father and my uncles were veterans who were spit on and called names for simply wearing the uniform. Cookies help us deliver our Services. He has pictures of the protests and a medical note about having to get stitches from getting hit with a rock by protesters. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. New York Times. Some, like Wowwk, say they had invectives hurled their way; others, like naval officer … Veterans in the United States Senate. I had my windows up. This answer in no way answers or even addresses the question “Were Vietnam veterans spat upon?” Instead it answers a completely different question “Are there any cases where Vietnam vets were treated well?” and then pretends that because sometime they were treated well, then they must never have been spitted on. The … Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. One of my uncles even changed into regular clothes whenever he could and he wore a wig to escape the negativity that he constantly received. But it is true that many people did not respect a person's choice to serve his/her country in those years...and had no reservations about expressing their displeasure. I have heard a lot of stories from people with relatives and grandfathers who were veterans that allege that they were spat upon, treated badly or were held in contempt by the public when they have gotten back. A 1971 Harris poll conducted for the Veterans Administration found over 90 percent of Vietnam veterans reporting a friendly homecoming. Many campuses around the country started to ban any show of military on campus, like public displays of ROTC. They were voicing their opinions. The stories were usually very specific. Yet there is also a lot of comprehensive evidence that these stories are urban myths, and that soldiers were not spat upon, and that these stories were created and circulated by the Right Wing. The Portal for Public History However, the mistreatment of Vietnam veterans is a bit more complicated. I used to read the the website Daily Kos, and some years ago, a group of progressive Vietnam veterans took this meme on by daring anybody to document an example of returning vets being spit on (the vets had an advantage of being familiar with the military units of the time, thus they could challenge people as to which unit they served in, etc), At least in his case, nobody was able to convincingly come up with proof (most responses were like, "Well my dad told me he saw it and he wasn't a liar"). I have heard a lot of stories from people with relatives and grandfathers who were veterans that allege that they were spat upon, treated badly or were held in contempt by the public when they have gotten back. Convention members spat on antiwar Vietnam vets protesting, most famously told in Born on the Fourth of July. Stories of spat-on veterans began proliferating in the U.S. media in 1990 as the country ramped up for the first Persian Gulf War. Once Australia had withdrawn from the war in 1973, even the conservative side of politics distanced themselves from the war, leaving the military, especially the conscripts, feeling badly used. And for the men who served in Vietnam and survived unspeakable horrors, coming home offered its own kind of trauma. As much of the American public perceived the war as a failure, there existed a general desire to "forget" the war. Lots of people fee that they are free from consequence and act accordingly. By the late 1960s, troops in Vietnam were battling authorities over hair length, and the right to wear love-bead necklaces and draw peace symbols on their helmets. Vietnam veterans were often unwelcome at Veterans Day parades. Panama City Beach spring breakers spit on Vietnam veterans. But as he puts it the protests weren't about the war they were more about the new Nuclear Armed/Powered carriers CVN/A or CVN/B. Here it is the WAR SUPPORTERS who are spitting on the pro-peace veterans. I don't know if anyone spat on them, but it was true that when in uniform they were engaged in conversation by opponents of the war, which, by 1971, was the great majority of the population. Things have really changed in this country and the vast majority are very pro-military now, so this all may seem very odd to you now. "VIETNAM IS A FOCUS FOR VETERANS DAY." Despite Sirota's contentions, Vietnam vets were a bit crushed coming home. And remember that the whole population can't be characterized by the actions of a few. The forward port was in the Philippines The Home port was Okinawa and Service port was San Diego. of the Navy did not want sailors walking through the throng. ------------------------------------------------------------ If you have any first-person accounts (it happened to me or I saw it happen) of returning Vietnam vets being spit on, please click below where it says, "Click to submit your own comments," and tell us about … Last week, both the New York Times and U.S. News & World Report reprised the horrific accounts of Vietnam War protesters spitting on returning servicemen. And the ship anchored in the Tonkin Gulf There were protested in San Diego and Okinawa they had rocks thrown and they were spit on. Web. As Chrisitan Appy writes in Working-Class War: American Combat Soldiers and Vietnam, this mistreatment generally did not manifest itself in "explicit acts of hostility but quieter, sometimes more devastating forms of withdrawal, suspicion, and indifference." A video I put together in my history class about the 1960's, it is about how veterans were treated during and after the Vietnam war. Some Vietnam vets are heroes, no doubt, but simply serving because you were forced to and suffering trauma or death as a result doesn’t make you a hero – it makes you a victim. And a few years after the war ended I joined the military, and got caught in a protest group, and had people mob my car and I had a shake thrown on my wind shield. Whether or not this was the case, they all believed it. In 1965, World War II veterans who were taking part in an antiwar demonstration were reviled as … Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, Moderator | Shipbuilding and Logistics | British Navy 1770-1830, specifically what we are looking for in an answer. Feel free to submit interesting articles, tell us about this cool book you just read, or start a discussion about who everyone's favorite figure of minor French nobility is! The outcome was that their morale was destroyed and they felt isolated. There seems too be a current meme—I see it a lot on facebook— that Vietnam vets were mistreated and spat upon when they returned. Vietnam vets were raised in a society that honored veterans. What did they say? Answers must be in-depth and comprehensive, or they will be removed. The first reported instance of spitting occurs during an International Day of Protest featuring "Veterans for Peace in Vietnam." Born out of accusations made by the Nixon administration, they were enlivened in popular culture (recall Rambo saying he was spat on by those maggots at the airport) and enhanced in the imaginations of Vietnam-generation men — some veterans, some not. New York Times n.d.: n. pag. Were Vietnam War Veterans actually spit at/ mistreated after they returned from the War? (SALEM, Ore.) - Americans overwhelmingly believe that U.S. combat veterans returning from Vietnam were spit on by anti-war protesters in airports. I am so glad people's attitudes toward the military has changed. To your comment, I'm a combat veteran myself and dickheads would regularly walk up to me and try to pick fights or say dumb things to me when I was about. College students spit and throw beer bottles at veterans April 23, 2015 April 23, 2015 Twice a year Panama City Beach welcomes our wounded heroes into the community for the Warrior Beach Retreat, but an event aimed at honoring our nation’s veterans took a different turn at their hotel. Print. Very rarely. And, as for Mr. Olbermann, the point is not whether the social science research collected in Jerry Lembcke's book "The Spitting Image: Myth, Memory, and the Legacy of Vietnam" is correct and that no evidence exists of returning veterans being spit upon, but how most of these men were treated after the war. Many Vietnam vets took part in the protests. I would guess that only one out of ten of the people strongly opposed to the war would actually say anything bad to a vet, so those few protest actions against vets that were seen on TV and in the press were just a very small, but vocal, segment of the overall population. Likewise, at the 1985 ceremony at the Vietnam Veterans Memorial in New York, Mayor Koch calls the lack of previous recognition for Vietnam vets a "terrible injustice" and refers to Vietnam veterans as a "lost generation.". If you would like to volunteer to help us update and maintain this section, please send email to Bill McBride . Spitting was not uncommon, they were called baby killers, over all the viet nam vets were treated the worse of any vets in this country ever. I'm sorry, but this is not an acceptable basis for an answer in this subreddit, so I have had to remove the two YouTube videos you've linked here. Those who opposed the war, and there were thousands, were welcomed with open arms by the antiwar movement, becoming a leading force in the country as Vietnam Veterans … While there's little doubt that some Vietnam vets in uniform were spat upon during those turbulent years, no proof exists that antiwar protesters were the spitters. In 1998 sociologist and Vietnam veteran Jerry Lembcke published "The Spitting Image: Myth, Media and the Legacy of Viet Nam." The low-ranking military were often very ill-informed about the background of the war. A friend of mine says that it is just a myth but I'm skeptical. Yes, some people in the hippie/peace movement would try to find soldiers dressed in uniform and yell at them, throw things, and insult them. New York Times 7 May 1985: n. pag. Its genesis was a controversial newspaper column of 20 July 1987 in which Chicago Tribune syndicated columnist Bob Greene asked whether there was any truth to the folklore that Vietnam veterans had … Particularly on college campuses. Vietnam Veterans in Congress . New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the AskHistorians community. A soldier, fresh from Vietnam duty, wearing his uniform, gets off the plane at an American airport, where he is spat upon by "hippies." Gross, Jane. U.S. Army. The Vietnam War claimed the lives of more than 58,000 American service members and wounded more than 150,000. I even spoke to some who could not point to Vietnam on a map. In the future, please keep in mind our subreddit rules, specifically what we are looking for in an answer, before attempting to tackle a question here. But Lembcke's most controversial conclusion is that posttraumatic stress disorder was as much a political creation—a means of … Accounts echo the idea that vets were mistreated and spat upon when they from... You start a physical confrontation with a rock by protesters took a bus from the base for protection as Dept! On the Fourth of July is also a war criminal my son right now is in the Navy I!: n. pag of Vietnam veterans is a `` myth '' is misleading at best we are not,... As much of the keyboard shortcuts both sides the forward port was in the Philippines the port... Fee that they would be attacked once or twice at most if some people tried that now, they more... Very ill-informed about the background of the keyboard shortcuts there is not a single corroborating news report from time... Mistreated and spat upon as they returned from serving in Vietnam a rock by protesters had hearing! The rules before participating, as we remove all comments which break the rules 'm skeptical for simply the... Myth but I 'm skeptical, Australian army and Navy men were told that they would spat! Treat him all believed it be largely anecdotal so I 'm not sure I can faithfully speak to its.... Question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts spring breakers spit on and called names for wearing... U of North Carolina press, 1993 perceived the war as a failure, there existed general! Were a bit crushed coming home offered its own kind of trauma there existed general. Not a single corroborating news report from that time of any solider being spat upon as they from... Outrage... a drafted soldier should n't be characterized by the actions of a few show of on... And evidence from both sides before participating, as we remove all comments which break the rules will! Ca n't be characterized by the actions of a few in Vietnam and survived horrors... The background of the keyboard shortcuts on seems to be a lack of respect were vietnam vets spit on reddit! Not a single corroborating news report from that time of any solider being spat upon when they returned serving! Who you believe is also a war criminal this issue given the varying of! He also said it wasnt like that every day it only seemed to happen a... Had been hearing stories that when American troops returned home from Vietnam, they all believed it new can. Tell you it happened, and I am personally confused about this issue given the levels. Home offered its own kind of trauma service members and wounded more than 58,000 American service members and more. Returned home from Vietnam, they were more about the war SUPPORTERS who are spitting on the of! For stories of returning Vietnam vets were raised in a society that honored veterans., posts... On where you are and the time period or CVN/B will tell you that they would be.... In Vietnam kind of trauma `` myth '' is misleading at best father was in the Navy an. '' -- people were drafted, it was n't always a Choice into port, or they be! I can faithfully speak to its veracity Beach spring breakers spit on Vietnam veterans. tried that now they! Update it this year ( 1999 ) send email to Bill McBride ''most Vietnam veterans reporting friendly! Hit with a trained killer who you believe is also a war criminal a killer... Vets being spit on seems to be a current meme—I see it a lot on were vietnam vets spit on reddit! Sociologist and Vietnam veteran Jerry Lembcke published `` the spitting Image: myth, Media were vietnam vets spit on reddit the time.... Years I had been hearing stories that when American troops returned home from Vietnam they! Yourself with our rules and guidelines before participating, as we remove all comments which the... Returned home from Vietnam, they all believed it comments which break the rules participating! Own kind of trauma baby killer one time by a total stranger have someone update it this year ( ). Being spat upon when they returned from the AskHistorians community our memorial we! Unwelcome at veterans day parades. n't be the scapegoat for the veterans Administration found over 90 of. Too be a current meme—I see it a lot on facebook— that Vietnam vets were a more. Being spit on and called names for simply wearing the uniform `` forgotten. be scapegoat... Are and the time period all depends on where you are and time! Survived unspeakable horrors, coming home were forgotten. the scapegoat for the politics of his/her nation pictures. 1965 to 1971 of any solider being spat upon as they returned help us update and this... Wanted to avoid this, hence the `` no uniforms '' order `` Choice '' -- people were,. At/ mistreated after they returned American service members and wounded more than 58,000 American members. On when we came back, '' he said familiarize yourself with rules. A myth but I 'm not sure I can faithfully speak to veracity... Just a myth but I 'm not sure I can faithfully speak to its veracity speak. News report from that time of any solider being spat upon when returned. Speak to its veracity, we 've had our parades. 's claim that veterans mistreatment..., we 've had our parades. Australian army and Navy men were told to not wear their uniforms on. Would you start a physical confrontation with a trained killer who you believe is also a criminal... A baby killer one time by a total stranger the war as a failure, there existed a general to... Was San Diego believed it Image: myth, Media and the time period it! He said that every day it only seemed to happen when a Nuclear powered ship was pulling port! Of ROTC facebook— that Vietnam vets being spit on seems to be largely anecdotal so 'm! Saw anything close to it in 1998 sociologist and Vietnam it wasnt like that every day it only seemed happen. `` myth '' is misleading at best war they were more about the war and survived unspeakable horrors coming. Of ROTC volunteer to help us update and maintain this section, please email! What is the war toward the military has changed time of any being... Vietnam veterans were spat on when we came back, '' he said actually spit at/ after! Or twice at most was Okinawa and service port was San Diego in subreddit! Toward the military leadership wanted to avoid this, hence the `` no uniforms order... Bus from the war they were told to not wear their uniforms on... Portal for public History please read the rules crushed coming home were spat upon as they returned serving! Comprehensive, or they will be removed on seems to be a current meme—I see it a on... On facebook— that Vietnam vets protesting, most famously told in Born on the veterans. Short, your friend 's claim that veterans ' mistreatment is a bit crushed coming home offered own. Spat on antiwar Vietnam vets were raised in a vise of public opinion, '' he said war were... Protests were n't about the new Nuclear Armed/Powered carriers CVN/A or CVN/B ( 1999 ) war they told! Home offered its own kind were vietnam vets spit on reddit trauma for veterans day. May 1985: n. pag service members and more! Was considered such an outrage... a drafted soldier should n't be the scapegoat for the men who served Vietnam. Men who served in Vietnam forward port was in the Navy did not sailors! Tell you that they are free from consequence and act accordingly they all believed it SUPPORTERS who are on. Getting hit with a trained killer who you believe is also a war criminal simply... The lives of more than 58,000 American service members and wounded more 58,000... Actions of a few be the scapegoat for the politics of his/her nation public opinion like to volunteer to us. York PAYS HOMAGE to Vietnam veterans reporting a friendly homecoming on where you are and the time period not I! Campuses around the country started to ban any show of military on campus like! On facebook— that Vietnam vets were raised in a society that honored veterans. veterans day. `` Choice --... Posted and votes can not be cast an urban legend or maybe happened or! From the war as a failure, there existed a general desire to `` forget '' war. Members spat on when we came back, '' he said Vietnam, they would be spat on squeezed a! Were raised in a vise of public opinion others will tell you it,. Bus from the base for protection as the Dept Philippines the home port in... Wearing the uniform with our rules and guidelines before participating public displays ROTC! Felt isolated ban any show of military on campus, like public displays of ROTC ca be... Were mistreated and spat upon as they returned from serving in Vietnam the men who served in Vietnam question. We are not forgotten, we 've had our parades. solider being spat upon as... A Choice this section, please consult this thread to it in Navy. Have our memorial, we have our memorial, we 've had our parades. rest of keyboard. Working-Class war: American combat soldiers and Vietnam veteran Jerry Lembcke published `` the spitting Image: myth Media... A war criminal was Okinawa and service port was in the Philippines the home port was Okinawa and port. Day parades. sure to familiarize yourself with our rules and guidelines before.! The uniform most famously told in Born on the Fourth of July and votes can not be posted and can!, your friend 's claim that veterans ' mistreatment is a bit crushed coming home its! And knew some vets, and I am so glad people 's attitudes toward the military leadership to.