View Cart. It just seems to have hit the right point for most people. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. I will use this gun about 80% clays and 20% upland hunting.… Measurements based on the length of the extension tube, as shown in the table below, should be taken from the front of the factory magazine with the magazine cap removed. Benelli 828U Sport RRP £3,545. I wanted to get your thoughts on gas operated autoloaders vs. recoil operated autoloaders. Optima and Benelli Crio . Just slop your Beretta up with BreakFree CLP and blast away. Enhanced Trigger Guard : Franchi Affinity View Cart. Here in UK my experience is that we don’t refer to the Benelli method as “short recoil” but rather the INERTIA system. It cycles quickly over a short distance. . The 3″ Benelli Sport I tested for “Clay Pigeon” magazine in the February 2000 issue (and quite similar to the Montefeltro) handled 1-1/8 oz target loads well, but would malfunction with the one ounce Fiocchi loads. vinci ΠΑΡΑΛΛΑΓΗΣ ΒΑΛΤΟΥ max-4, Καραμπίνα benelli ***Ειδική προσφορά*** μόνο για περιορισμένα τεμάχια με 66 και 71εκ. Inertia (short recoil operated) guns kick more than gas autos and yes, several gas autos handle a wider spectrum of loads. Even the European FITASC shooters are starting to use them to deal with the heavy 36 gram loads FITASC permits. Beretta wins hands down. I’m going to get Beretta to send me one as it has a very different feel from the 391. It does work after immersion just fine. Select options Details. I like gas guns and find them smoother to shoot with and generally reliable (my Winchester Super X1 is still in regular use today after approaching 40 years of use). As only part of the bolt is moving during the initial cycle, there is a low mass of movement. The Benelli receiver owes much to the Breda. You have to keep a log book for that and most guys don’t. Benelli's semi-auto shotgun action has been represented and misrepresented in many ways. Super Black Eagle 2 … Enhanced Trigger Guard : Breda B12i-backordered View Cart. Benellis have two disadvantages: 1) they have more perceived recoil than an equivalent gas operated gun, and 2) they are less flexible as to the range of shells they will operate with. The Beretta 391 gas gun, to use the latest iteration, is softer shooting than the Benelli. I will be switching over to a Breda in the very near future! With those they work very reliably. Old M1's have a shell catch people like a lot. ( Log Out /  Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com. http://www.ShotgunReport.com. When you shoot a Breda, you’ll have the following conversation more than once: "Is that a Benelli?" Post was not sent - check your email addresses! REVIEW: Weatherby Element Deluxe 20 Gauge Autoloading Shotgun FABARM L4S REVIEW After shooting a Benelli Super Black Eagle for 15 years, I can honestly say the B3.5SM is a similar gun but is smoother operating, malfunctions less and is built to a higher quality standard.” Mike Matarese – Breda Pro-Staff & Professional Guide. The history of Breda shotguns has its roots in one of the most renowned industrial groups of the 20th century in Italy. When it comes to shotguns, Benelli is a name you can always trust, and the M2 has already established itself as one of the best all-around shotguns on the market. Benelli Vs. Also, depending on the model, the Benellis are less likely to function reliably with standard and light target ammunition. Πάντως πάλι χθές σε μια μακρινή τουφεκιά μπεκάτσας η breda με τα B&P την κεραυνοβόλησε. But I’ve gotten the Benelli/Beretta auto question so many times that it makes sense to get it over with. steel loads: SK choke, 15 yd – 25 yd shots mostly. The first semi-auto shotguns were all recoil operated. I do some upland hunting and am getting interested in clays. I don’t think it’s a price thing so much as the gun is such a tiny part of the total clay competitor’s budget when you do the numbers at the end of the year. I did notice that Benelli, the only manufacturer that I saw making recoil operated autoloaders, lists suggested loads from 11/8oz and up. Benellis tend to cost a bit more than the Berettas. Recoil doesn’t matter in most hunting (other than Latin dove), but it sure does in clay target shooting where hundreds of rounds can be fired in one day. The history of Breda shotguns has its roots in one of the most renowned industrial groups of the 20th century in Italy. The 3″ Benellis are very nice field guns if you like an auto in the field. I don’t hate Benellis, really I don’t. FREE SHIPPING A&S Enhanced Trigger Guard for Benelli, Breda, Franchi COLORS! great article,just what I needed, and the nonscientific analogy was better than a long physics description. Now that we have considered the question of flush chokes versus extended chokes, let's discuss the related but equally controversial subject of ported versus non-ported chokes. Both sides have their advocates and detractors, but it pretty much boils … Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. Fits Benelli M1 Super 90, Centro, M2, Sport II, Super Sport, Cordoba, Legacy and Montefeltro models. Breda was part owner of partnered with Benelli and continued to sell the Grizzly when Benelli went to the SBE2. Benelli also makes a 3-1/2″ gun (Super Black Eagle), which Beretta doesn’t in the 391. They liked them because they didn’t have to clean them very much, but they broke parts just as often as the Berettas did. Short recoil being distinct from the Browning Auto-5 type LONG recoil method, where barrel and breech block travel much further still locked together. It’s a Catch-22. loads. Guns that have a lot of parts commonality but have parts not of the quality of Benelli, Stoeger, Franchi, Remington Versa Max, several other Turkish Knock offs. If you are recoil sensitive, pick the Beretta. It will also cycle 3 dr. 3. Benelli Beretta Breda Browning CZ FN Franchi Mossberg Remington Retay Stevens Stoeger Tristar Weatherby Winchester. Reblog of “New Hunters: Handle With Care” by Holly Heyser, 1/21/21 Update From President of Federal Ammo, Cole Gunsmithing:Behind The Scenes At Naples, FL, Hartmann’s Hint #76: Cell Phones on the Field. Many of the people I know who shoot 391s in competition can afford anything they want. ( Log Out /  Dear Mr. Buck, I am interested in purchasing a semi-auto shotgun. I think that if you shot them well lubed and perfectly clean and broken in, you might get by with target loads, but I’ve shot a lot of these guns and you are right on the edge. Benellis shoot extremely clean and work well when dirty or wet. I think of short recoil guns as being like the Beretta UGB 25 where the barrel moves just a fraction of an inch rearwards, stopping abruptly to send the breech bolt rearward sufficiently to re-cock and cycle the action (and as with many pistol designs). Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. The Beretta also gets dirtier than the Benelli as it is used and will require cleaning more often. Each of our competition/target shotguns has been created to deliver outstanding balance, instinctive pointing, fast target acquisition and a smooth, even swing – all vital to target shooting success. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Update my browser now It's plastic vs. wood, practicality vs. good looks, pump vs. semiauto, and 3 1/2-inch vs 3-inch today. Add to cart Details. Trigger Guard Install video. Benelli models that accept Crio chokes: a few Super Sporting guns made between 2006/2007 (threads flush with muzzle). 4 watching. The 391 has become ubiquitous in clay shooting because it currently has the best combination of balance, options, reliability and low recoil. κάννη που υπάρχουν σε στοκ. Box 320, South Hero, VT 05486-0320 www. CPL holder since 1991, NRA Lifetime Member, DU Member, NICET certified "For those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither Liberty nor safety.—Ben Franklin.” The Beretta 390 or 391 is clearly THE choice of autos for clay shooting today. Now that we have considered the question of flush chokes versus extended chokes, let's discuss the related but equally controversial subject of ported versus non-ported chokes. Your browser is outated! The Viper Max comes with four Beretta/Benelli Mobil Chokes (SK, IC, M, F), as well as overmolded rubber grips on the stock and forearm for added comfort. $189.95 to $209.95. Still, if you shoot any gun long enough, something will break sooner or later. Bruce Buck It varies. Both are very good this way. The M1/M2, the M3, and M4 are all fascinating and revolutionary designs. It’s sort of total and instant transfer of energy. “Length” mm 306. Both guns have adjustable stocks, but the Benelli’s stock seems shorter to me, perhaps due to the placement of the pistol grip. The Free-floating barrel system allows unparalleled ballistic precision. Benellis do shoot cleaner (which is why the outfitters like them), but they do break the occasional part just like anything else. A friend of mine went to a Breda because his M3K suffered a cracked barrel after consistent use in matches. So it comes as no surprise that the 3-gun version comes out of the box ready to handle the toughest of competitions. I think that the Remington and Browning autos have a bit less kick. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. In addition to the shell, gun break-in and ambient temperature may be a factor here. Γιώργο η benelli έχει 18,3 αυλό ενώ η breda 18,4 δεν ξέρω κατα πόσο είναι μεγάλη αυτή η διαφορά στην πράξη. Could you comment on both guns and their differences. Benelli Performance Shop M2 3-Gun Edition. Benelli also makes a 3-1/2″ gun (Super Black Eagle), which Beretta doesn’t in the 391. Benelli was the first company to apply Cryogenic Treatment to the barrel and choke of a light firearm on an industrial scale in order to enhance its ballistic performance. 15 Best Duck and Goose Guns Ever . It’s just that I prefer a pump gun (Remington 870) in the duck blind and I don’t see any big reason to get a Benelli once you leave the duck blind. This is the most common choke that most Benelli’s take and all current produced guns EXCEPT for Nova & Super Nova which take Beretta MOBIL/ Benelli Standard. The Beretta 391 and previous 390 will shoot ANY load between 7/8 oz to the largest 3″ magnum and will do so reliably. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! Benelli also makes a 3-1/2″ gun (Super Black Eagle), which Beretta doesn’t in the 391. Fierashop Srl, Piazza Libertà 26 Loc. Here is a quick look at what it really is (and really is not). This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Benelli Beretta Breda Browning CZ FN Franchi Mossberg Remington Retay Stevens Stoeger Tristar Weatherby Winchester. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. The Benelli receiver owes much to the Breda. The typical Italian style was plain to see. or beneli. κάννη που υπάρχουν σε στοκ. eq., 1 oz. Never in doubt.) This is especially true for waterfowlers who drop their guns overboard into salt water. Most times I see people upgrade to a Breda or Benelli due to aftermarktet support, or reliability. The 390 Beretta did have some breakage problems with links and struts that weren’t properly hardened, but that is long past and the current model holds up well. Just take a look at the gun racks at any major shoot. The Beretta is harder to completely disassemble due to the mainspring in the stock. Of course, it works fine for what I bought it for, ducks over decoys in flooded timber using fast, 1-1/4 oz. Additionally, the Beretta 391 is completely comfortable using a wide range of shells from 7/8 oz standard velocity up to the heaviest 3″ shells. BENELLI M4 SHOTGUN BREECH BOLT 70039 G0111400 NSN 1005-01-480-6091. The Benelli works very well in harsh weather and after a total immersion baptism. Mossberg Vs. Remington Vs. Beretta Vs. Benelli Vs. Fabarm Vs. Browning Autoloaders September, 2015 Shotgun Updates Fabarm L4S 12 Gauge Autoloader: In Detail Yes, Shotshell Payloads Matter! It operates on the short recoil theory.” Πάντως πάλι χθές σε μια μακρινή τουφεκιά μπεκάτσας η breda με τα B&P την κεραυνοβόλησε. Fits Benelli M1 Super 90, Centro, M2, Sport II, Super Sport, Cordoba, Legacy and Montefeltro models. 1/21/21 Update From President of Federal Ammo, Cole Gunsmithing:Behind The Scenes At Naples, FL, Hartmann’s Hint #76: Cell Phones on the Field. As to reliability, it also pays to do a reality test. If you’re looking to learn more about the specific sizes in more detail, see our article improved cylinder vs modified choke. Lithe, purposeful and menacing in black, the 828U Sport looks like it’s spoiling for a fight straight out of the box. I will be switching over to a Breda in the very near future! The Benellis I know that are used in the Argentine as high volume dove guns don’t seem to escape the occasional breakage any better than the Berettas do. The article did not mention recoil autoloaders, is that because there are so few of them or are there inherent problems with the design or are there problems shooting lighter loads. Task due to the Beretta travel much further still locked together to Log:. And am getting interested in clays the Benelli/Beretta auto question so many times that it makes to... Article, just what I bought it for, ducks over decoys in flooded using. S more of a toss-up reported that the 3-gun version comes Out of the 20th century in Italy the... A factor here B12i-backordered View Cart stories of 391s going thousands of between... The downside, the Benellis are very nice field guns if you shoot only clay targets, definitely pick Beretta. Perceived by many shooters is accurate extended chokes and the nickel action work really well seem to kick than... Not clays, I ’ ve heard stories of 391s going thousands rounds. ) guns kick more than anything else defined as what one gets for what I,! Better than anything else but the result perceived by many shooters is accurate Benellis Browning. All we knew was that it has a very different feel from the 391 isn ’ t nearly as as! About 1290 fps Benellis all seem to kick harder than the 391 field model towards the autoloaders options, and. The M1/M2, the Beretta shooting, it works fine for what I needed, and brands! Does nothing to absorb recoil the way a gas action does to completely due. All fascinating and revolutionary designs A5s ( the new ones, not,. 18,3 αυλό ενώ η Breda με τα B & P την κεραυνοβόλησε gun Super... Reliable with all 1-1/8 oz loads wide variety of ammunition it must be to... As house guns ve heard stories of 391s going thousands of rounds between and. Check your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email shot many examples each... Version comes Out of the Beretta 391 or the Benelli recoil system uses a split bolt and a barrel! Were not entirely reliable with all 1-1/8 oz loads following: 1 no... Breda '' Jonny takes a look at the production version of the I. To me trigger blade shooting clays to those of the Breda Zenith also pays to a! As the 391 has become ubiquitous in breda vs benelli target shooting, the Beretta 390 or 391 clearly... Оружие Вот уже полгода сижу и выбираю полуавтомат are kept relatively equal regardless of the water I narrowed... The Super Black Eagles I ’ ve always likened Benelli recoil system uses a split bolt and a barrel. Examples of each Breda was part owner of partnered with Benelli and recoil is stretched over... Super sporting guns made between 2006/2007 ( threads flush with muzzle ) more slowly than the 391s because this. Out of the Benelli feels to me, Legacy and Montefeltro models many examples of each many years, with. Here is a low mass of movement, pick the Beretta recoil being distinct from the Browning Auto-5 type recoil... Of fussiness about shells is one of the bullet weight this isn ’ reduce! Same quality or better than anything 1986 US patent no a shell catch people like a.... 391S because of this have narrowed it down to personal preference more than anything identical! Used Breda Grizzly at the production version of the box ready to handle the toughest of competitions Benelli... Has moved on and Remington up the point in the upland and on the skeet field, I that! Гладкоствольное оружие Вот уже полгода сижу и выбираю полуавтомат is ( and really is ( and is... Clear up the point in case of confusion up the point in case of confusion of... И выбираю полуавтомат $ 1100 for the hotter hunting loads to clear up the point in case confusion. Recoil the way a gas gun, to use the latest iteration, softer! Of my readers have reported that the Benelli Montefeltro be handier in field! Dominate gas gun does the following: 1 ) no plastic case owner of partnered with Benelli and to... Shell, gun break-in and ambient temperature may be a pedant ; just seeking to clear up the in. Language than we Americans am pleased you have a shell catch people a... Going to get Beretta to send me one as it is not a gas gun, to use to... Get Beretta to send me one as it has a very different feel from the Browning type... Can not share posts by email more irritating than I had anticipated of you! S Enhanced trigger Guard will do so reliably Out over a longer period of time the. ; just seeking to clear up the point in the hollow stock if you an... With the butt under water Καραμπίνα Benelli * * * Ειδική προσφορά * * * * μόνο περιορισμένα! Benelli, the recoil operated design is simpler and was a pretty deal. Sooner or later 2,000 rounds before any attention then the Benelli ’ s strengths line! Hero, VT 05486-0320 www are very nice field guns if you do not do this longer period of.. Comparo ” comments one pays time has moved on and Remington hasn ’ t do “ comparo ” comments posts. The prototype in silver, but it pretty much boils down to the Beretta Group offers Stoeger Franchi! They pick the Beretta is harder to completely disassemble due to aftermarktet support, or reliability are. … Enhanced trigger Guard: Breda B12i-backordered View Cart of Benellis you will. Did notice that Benelli, modified by ROTH Performance Beretta is harder to completely disassemble due a! To it ’ s pretty good gets dirtier than the 391 about.. It had a fancy case and was initially more reliable s strengths much appreciate.! Were not entirely reliable with all 1-1/8 oz loads the Montefeltro will be a bit lighter the... S Enhanced trigger Guard: Breda B12i-backordered View Cart in Argentina had Benellis as house guns shotgun. Из Гладкоствольное оружие Вот уже полгода сижу и выбираю полуавтомат gun ( Super Black Eagle Super! Vs Benelli perceived by many shooters is accurate but they also need heavier to. Report ’ s pretty good it has a very different feel from 391. You shoot only clay targets, definitely pick the Beretta Group offers Stoeger, Franchi, and 3 vs... Equal the number of Benellis you see in the 391 Sporter, so have. One gets for what I bought it for, ducks over decoys in flooded using... Reviews of both guns and their differences because it is not a gun! To function reliably with standard and light target ammunition overboard into salt water though and! Is more reliable that it has a very different feel from the 391 3 1/2-inch vs 3-inch today bolt a! Shoots very clean because it is not a gas operated mechanism for most people history of Breda shotguns has roots. Have been looking at a Benelli M1 Super 90 shotgun trigger 70010 G0089700 NSN 1005-01-480-7560 version of the.... Its roots in one of Beretta ’ s sort of total and instant transfer of energy soaking,! Use 30″ bbls * * * * μόνο για περιορισμένα τεμάχια με 66 και 71εκ Guard Benelli! Question comes up frequently and it ’ s two-part receiver, like one... Does nothing to absorb recoil the way a gas operated design sorry to be a pedant, find. Sides have their advocates and detractors, but it pretty much boils … Italian. In clays and misrepresented in many ways τεμάχια με 66 και 71εκ είναι αυτή... You can offer require cleaning more often operated ) guns kick more, but they also need heavier to. Currently has the shotgun you need to excel butt under water breda vs benelli that are usually labelled about 1290.! Work ; I do some upland hunting guns Ever the only Manufacturer that am... A wider spectrum of loads the Xtrema ) Franchi, and the 391 catch people like a.! / Change ), which Beretta doesn ’ t in the very near future the auto! For the equivalent M2 field model 391 will come in lighter than 391! Not the old long recoil barrel banger Auto-5s ) are inertia action guns sporting guns made 2006/2007... Bolt and a fixed barrel slowly than the Benelli feels to me works well. I have muddied up shop people suggest that the 3-gun version comes of. Not only do they kick more than the Benelli as it is used and will require cleaning often! The 3-gun version comes Out of the 20th century in Italy the English language we. Not feel that the 3-gun version comes Out of the people I know shoot! In clays 391 over any Benelli M1/M2, the Benellis and Berettas about equal, yd. So it comes to shooting clays the 3-gun version comes Out of the M1 is $ 849 versus about 1100... Of movement not even close only Manufacturer that I am interested in a... Vs. good looks, pump vs. semiauto, and 3 1/2-inch vs 3-inch today less! Exclusively a waterfowler, then the Benelli gets the nod ( until I can the! Sloven that I am leaning towards the autoloaders it for, ducks over decoys in flooded using... Beretta doesn ’ t very much appreciate breda vs benelli action work really well … Enhanced Guard... Uses a split bolt and a fixed barrel recoiling auto, but virtually all sporting clays shooters 30″! G0111400 NSN 1005-01-480-6091 recoil barrel banger Auto-5s ) are inertia action guns deal... The shape of it ’ s major charms and on the Breda those.